10 Best Horror TV Shows Of The 21st Century
They have covered events, such as the Denver Fan Expo. Professionals in the field, such as Damien Leone and Lucy Hale, have shared their articles. Their review of Ponies was quoted in the show's TV trailer.
In university, they majored in English Writing with a minor in psychology. They have always had a passion for analyzing TV and movies, even taking filmography and scriptwriting classes in university. They also studied and participated in onstage and onscreen acting extensively from the ages of 7 to 18.
Aside from working at Screen Rant, Dani has worked as a freelance editor and writer over the past decade, often in a ghostwriting capacity.
Although there are many great competitors, these ten horror TV shows stand out as fan favorites and the best of the 21st century. Some of the best horror shows of all time, such as The Twilight Zone and Tales from the Crypt, released in the 1900s. However, the genre is seeing a renaissance. The new millennium has been a delight for horror lovers, as horror is more mainstream than ever before. Network TV and streamers alike have both invested time and money in creating long-form stories that deliver nightmare fuel that lingers long after the last episode.
Not every horror show lands quite as well as hoped, though. Some horror is just bad, and not in the enjoyable way. Because of too much melodrama and a thin story, Netflix’s Chambers just didn’t land. Similarly, South of Hell is perhaps one of the worst things made by Blumhouse Television, the small-screen branch of the horror production company. On the other end, the 21st century has brought fantastic TV shows that carved out their place as the best horror shows since the turn of the millennium
10 American Horror Story
American Horror Story reinvents itself each season with a repertory ensemble cast, making it unique in the horror genre. With 17 Emmys, 2 Golden Globes, and 12 seasons, it has established itself as a standout.
I’ll be upfront that I cannot stand American Horror Story, but I’d be remiss to exclude it because it’s one of the most popular horror shows this century. The series mashes together shock-horror and soapy storylines, making horror accessible to a wider audience. The production values are high, and it doesn’t reject campiness.
Additionally, American Horror Story has standout actors, like Sarah Paulson and Evan Peters, who consistently deliver strong performances. I can objectively see why people enjoy it. That said, the sensationalization of sexual assault and disability stereotypes is distasteful, so I cannot bring myself to put it anywhere but last place.
9 From
MGM+’s slow-burn horror From has garnered a massive following, with four seasons and a final season on the way. The show follows people trapped in a mysterious town where shapeshifting monsters emerge from the woods at night to hunt them.
The town's inescapability feels reminiscent of Derry, Maine or Silent Hill, creating a claustrophobic ambiance. The mystery heightens the uneasiness because the show provides just enough lore to hook audiences while keeping them guessing.
From also favors character-driven storytelling over constant shock-horror, and the grounded approach makes the terror feel more palpable. Unlike other shows, From isn’t afraid to kill its characters, raising the stakes. Additionally, the less frequent jump scares make them more impactful when they do happen. Though the quality dips slightly in season 2, From definitely earns its place as one of the best horror shows.
8 Widow’s Bay
Apple TV’s horror-comedy Widow’s Bay quickly established itself as one of the best horror TV shows of the 21st century. On a New England coastal island, Mayor Tom Loftis, a transplant from the mainland, pushes to increase tourism despite local belief that the town is cursed.
Widow’s Bay flawlessly blends horror and comedy, never sacrificing one for the other. The show draws on real superstitions and folklore, making the fears feel extremely grounded.
While every actor contributes to the show’s success, Matthew Rhys is the special ingredient that sets this show apart from competitors. The actor plays Loftis as the straight man archetype, and his comedic timing and reactions are on point. Rhys also has a masterful grasp of microexpressions, enhancing his performance. Ultimately, it’s no surprise that Widow’s Bay earned 19 Emmy nominations in its debut season.
7 Marianne
The French series Marianne has gained a cult following and is among this century's best horror series, despite not being mainstream. The story follows horror writer Emma Larsimon, who writes about a witch named Marianne. After ceasing her book series, she notices strange events that make her question whether the character could be real.
The show blurs the line between reality and fiction, giving it a Stephen King vibe. Marianne weaves together atmospheric horror, body horror, disturbing visuals, and occasional jump scares. Thomas Cappeau’s score subtly manipulates the audience’s nervous systems, building dread.
Marianne herself stands out as a villain because she’s terrifyingly human, with a sadistic nature and the ability to weaponize her victims’ trauma. At the same time, the makeup applied to the actor taps into the uncanny valley effect, where something seems just barely non-human.
6 Hannibal
Anthony Hopkins’ Hannibal Lecter is one of the best horror villains of all time, and Hannibal dared to reimagine the character in a long-form TV show, with Mads Mikkelsen in the title role. Shockingly, it became one of the best psychological horror TV shows of all time.
The show centers on the twisted relationship between FBI profiler Will Graham and forensic psychiatrist Hannibal Lecter, who is secretly the Chesapeake Ripper. Rather than focusing on the procedural aspects of investigations, the show zooms in on the main duo, highlighting their cat-and-mouse dynamic. Mikkelsen portrays Hannibal with chilling calm and subtlety, which contrasts with Will Graham’s mental fracturing.
Beyond the writing and acting, Hannibal truly thrives on its cinematography, lighting, and composition. Every decision behind the scenes feels intentional, elevating horrifying murders into an art form.
5 The Last Of Us
The apocalypse TV show The Last of Us is one of the best video game adaptations and horror TV shows of the 21st century. Set after a fungal infection causes societal collapse and zombies, the story follows a hardened survivor named Joel (Pedro Pascal) and an immune teenager named Ellie (Bella Ramsey) as they travel across the US.
Unlike many zombie stories, The Last of Us leans into realism, offering a plausible explanation for the outbreak using a real-world fungus. The show is fearless in its willingness to kill off characters. The man-eating creatures pose a real threat, as does the infection, heightening the tension.
Luckily, the show is slow-burn enough for us to get to know the characters but fast enough not to be a snooze-fest. Pascal and Ramsey’s strong performances make it easy for the audience to worry about their safety.
4 Penny Dreadful
While most TV shows lean toward modern horror, Penny Dreadful draws on 19th-century Victorian Gothic horror novels and conventions. A clairvoyant named Vanessa Ives, an American gunslinger Ethan Chandler, and retired explorer Sir Malcolm Murray encounter famous literary characters while investigating a supernatural mystery.
The show weaves together the stories of Frankenstein, Dracula, The Picture of Dorian Gray, The Strange Case of Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde, and The Misfortunes of Virtue. Stylistically, it leans heavily into the pulpy elements of the penny dreadfuls, lurid, sensationalized supernatural books from the 19th century, making it a delight for fans of Gothic stories.
Ultimately, the story might not be scary, but Penny Dreadful packs in disturbing gore, blood magic, and demons. It won’t seem like horror at first glance, but it’s an homage to the genre that was foundational to modern horror.
3 The Haunting Of Hill House
The Haunting of Hill House is a brilliant masterclass in blending supernatural horror with psychological drama. The story follows the five Crane siblings, alternating between their traumatic childhoods and their return to the haunted Hill House as adults.
Every member of The Haunting of Hill House’s cast brings their A-game, delivering compelling performances that ground the disturbing events in reality. However, Victoria Pedretti stands out, as this was not only her breakout role but also her best performance to date.
Rather than playing it safe, The Haunting of Hill House takes bold technical risks, including a 17-minute continuous shot requiring intricate set design and camerawork. It also enhances the eerie ambiance by hiding apparitions in the background. Ultimately, the strong collaboration between creator Mike Flanagan and cinematographer Michael Fimognari makes the story not only a horror masterpiece but also a technical gem.
2 Black Mirror
Netflix’s Black Mirror is often dismissed in horror discussions, getting labeled as sci-fi. Yet the show is emblematic of the techno-horror genre. There aren’t jump scares, gore, or supernatural forces to create fear. Instead, the stories fill viewers with paranoia and creeping existential dread induced by near-future technology that’s too close for comfort.
Like its spiritual predecessor, The Twilight Zone, each episode of Black Mirror brings a new, self-contained story that induces chills. They frequently explore the morally ambiguous, terrifying parts of humanity. What’s more, the series never shies away from social issues and critiques of capitalism, providing razor-sharp commentary.
Rather than having a set cast, the anthology cycles through actors, rarely bringing them back for more than 2 episodes. That makes it all the more impressive that it has a stacked cast of famous Hollywood names.
1 Midnight Mass
Midnight Mass blends monster horror and psychological terror into a cutting miniseries that examines how those in power can wield scripture as a weapon. The story follows the impoverished Catholic fishing community on Crockett Island as their lives are transformed by the new charismatic leader, Father Paul Hill. He might bring miracles, but he’s also hiding a supernatural secret.
Religious horror is nothing new, but Midnight Mass approaches the topic with nuance. Hesitant viewers should know that this isn’t anti-religion or anti-faith but anti-religious fanaticism of any kind. The ability to balance these perspectives is part of what makes Midnight Mass unique.
Additionally, the show beats out The Haunting of Hill House as Mike Flanagan’s best work. Midnight Mass has tighter writing, a deeper exploration of the human condition, and an unexpected ending that feels shocking yet earned.